Looking for a DynamicSPF replacement that actually works for Managed Service Providers?

AutoSPF is the best DynamicSPF alternative for MSPs looking to deliver scalable, automated SPF and DMARC management to their clients.

DynamicSPF by Dmarcduty is one of the better-known names in SPF record automation, but it isn’t the right fit for every Managed Service Provider (MSP).

For MSPs, protecting client domains from spoofing, phishing, and failed email delivery is mission-critical. SPF and DMARC are no longer optional — they’re core to keeping business email secure and ensuring reliable deliverability. But here’s the challenge: most tools on the market, including DynamicSPF, fall short when MSPs need:

  • Multi-tenant client management at scale
  • Automated record updates without manual intervention
  • Clear visibility into email authentication health
  • Predictable, partner-friendly pricing

That’s why many MSPs are now exploring DynamicSPF alternatives — tools that go beyond basic SPF record flattening and provide full automation, scalability, and security oversight.

In this guide, we’ll explore the 12 best alternatives to DynamicSPF in 2025, evaluating them by features, integrations, MSP-friendliness, support, and cost-effectiveness.

Let’s dive in.

What are the best alternatives to DynamicSPF by Dmarcduty?

The market offers a wide range of alternatives. Some are lightweight SPF record managers, while others provide full-scale DMARC, SPF, and DKIM compliance platforms tailored for MSPs.

Here are the top five overall competitors to DynamicSPF:

  • AutoSPF (best overall for MSPs)
  • Valimail
  • EasyDMARC
  • PowerDMARC
  • DMARC Analyzer (by Mimecast)

But there are at least 10 more serious competitors worth considering depending on your client mix and growth model.

Types of DynamicSPF Alternatives

When MSPs consider DynamicSPF replacements, they typically fall into two categories:

  1. SPF automation tools: Focused solely on flattening and maintaining SPF records dynamically. Simple, but often limited in scope.
  2. Full email authentication platforms (SPF + DKIM + DMARC): Comprehensive solutions for MSPs who need to manage entire authentication stacks, reporting, and compliance for dozens or hundreds of client domains.

The 12 Best DynamicSPF Alternatives in September 2025

1. AutoSPF

Best DynamicSPF alternative overall for MSPs

AutoSPF is built specifically for Managed Service Providers who need to manage SPF records across many client domains without hitting DNS lookup limits or juggling manual updates.

Unlike DynamicSPF, which focuses narrowly on record flattening, AutoSPF automates the entire SPF lifecycle:

  • Real-time record optimization
  • Automated DNS publishing
  • Multi-tenant dashboard for MSP oversight
  • Alerting when new services (like Salesforce, Google Workspace, or Microsoft 365) impact client SPF compliance

AutoSPF vs DynamicSPF: Key Differences

Feature AutoSPF DynamicSPF
Multi-tenant MSP dashboard ✅ Yes ❌ No
Automated DNS publishing ✅ Yes ❌ No (manual updates required)
Intelligent record flattening with loop prevention ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
Real-time monitoring + alerts ✅ Yes ❌ No
Partner-friendly pricing ✅ Yes ❌ No (usage-based, harder to scale)

What real MSPs say:
 “AutoSPF eliminated 90% of our manual SPF management workload across 40+ client domains. The multi-tenant dashboard is a lifesaver.” – Verified MSP Partner

Pricing & Support:

  • Partner-tier pricing for MSPs
  • 24/7 support with SLA-backed response times
  • Native integrations with Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, and DNS providers

👉 AutoSPF is the best choice if you want an MSP-first SPF automation platform that replaces DynamicSPF entirely and adds real scalability.

2. Valimail

Best for enterprise-grade DMARC automation

Valimail is a leader in the email authentication space, offering enterprise-level DMARC enforcement and strong brand protection features.

Valimail vs DynamicSPF

Feature Valimail DynamicSPF
SPF record flattening ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
DMARC enforcement ✅ Yes ❌ No
Advanced reporting ✅ Yes ❌ No
Multi-tenant MSP view ❌ Limited ❌ No

Valimail is feature-rich but can be expensive and less flexible for MSPs with small to mid-sized clients.

3. EasyDMARC

Best for MSPs needing reporting dashboards

EasyDMARC provides a balance of affordability and useful reporting, making it a popular pick for MSPs serving SMB clients.

  • Automated SPF/DKIM/DMARC management
  • Clear dashboards for non-technical stakeholders
  • Affordable pricing tiers

EasyDMARC vs DynamicSPF

Feature EasyDMARC DynamicSPF
SPF record automation ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
DMARC visibility ✅ Yes ❌ No
MSP partner program ✅ Yes ❌ No

4. PowerDMARC

Best for MSPs needing advanced security integrations

PowerDMARC is a robust platform combining SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI, and MTA-STS.

PowerDMARC vs DynamicSPF

Feature PowerDMARC DynamicSPF
SPF + DMARC support ✅ Yes ❌ No
Real-time threat intelligence ✅ Yes ❌ No
White-label MSP portal ✅ Yes ❌ No

Best suited for MSPs that want more than SPF management — especially those with clients in finance or healthcare.

5. DMARC Analyzer (Mimecast)

Best for MSPs already in the Mimecast ecosystem

DMARC Analyzer is Mimecast’s take on authentication management.

DMARC Analyzer vs DynamicSPF

Feature DMARC Analyzer DynamicSPF
SPF automation ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
Integrated with Mimecast security stack ✅ Yes ❌ No
MSP scalability ❌ Limited ❌ No

Good for enterprise MSPs with existing Mimecast clients but less flexible for SMB-focused providers.

6. OnDMARC (by Red Sift)

Best for MSPs wanting simplicity and visual clarity

OnDMARC emphasizes ease of use with visual dashboards and guided DMARC enforcement paths. It’s designed for organizations that want clarity without steep technical complexity.

OnDMARC vs DynamicSPF

Feature OnDMARC DynamicSPF
SPF management ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
Guided DMARC enforcement ✅ Yes ❌ No
Visual dashboards ✅ Yes ❌ No
MSP features ✅ Limited ❌ No

7. Agari (by Fortra)

Best for advanced phishing defense

Agari combines DMARC with AI-driven threat detection. It’s enterprise-heavy, but MSPs with clients in government, healthcare, or finance often value its proactive defense.

Agari vs DynamicSPF

Feature Agari DynamicSPF
SPF automation ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
AI-driven phishing detection ✅ Yes ❌ No
DMARC visibility ✅ Yes ❌ No

8. dmarcian

Best for MSPs who want educational resources

dmarcian focuses on DMARC adoption with user education, step-by-step guides, and compliance tracking.

dmarcian vs DynamicSPF

Feature dmarcian DynamicSPF
SPF flattening ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
DMARC adoption focus ✅ Yes ❌ No
MSP scalability ✅ Moderate ❌ No

9. Red Sift (full suite)

Best for MSPs needing integrated security stack

Red Sift offers more than OnDMARC, providing a full suite of cybersecurity solutions. Good for MSPs that want domain-wide monitoring.

10. Proofpoint Email Authentication

Best for compliance-heavy industries

Proofpoint adds authentication into a wider security portfolio. Great for MSPs in highly regulated spaces.

11. Cloudflare DMARC Management

Best for MSPs already using Cloudflare DNS

Streamlined SPF/DMARC management directly within Cloudflare’s ecosystem.

12. OpenDMARC (open-source)

Best for MSPs with in-house development teams

OpenDMARC gives full control but requires technical expertise.

Final Verdict: What’s the Best DynamicSPF Alternative for MSPs?

DynamicSPF was built for basic SPF flattening, but MSPs in 2025 need scalable, automated, and client-friendly solutions that handle SPF and DMARC management holistically.

  • If you want the best overall DynamicSPF alternative for MSPs → AutoSPF is your answer. Purpose-built for MSPs, it scales with you, automates everything, and provides partner-first pricing.
  • If you’re serving large enterprises → Valimail or Proofpoint may be more suitable.
  • If your clients are SMBs → EasyDMARC is a budget-conscious choice.
  • If you need advanced compliance & threat intel → PowerDMARC and Agari stand out.

👉 But for most Managed Service Providers who want a true replacement for DynamicSPF, AutoSPF leads the pack in 2025.